• 0 Posts
  • 1 Comment
Joined 14 days ago
cake
Cake day: November 8th, 2026

help-circle
  • Personally, I use ZFS heavily, and I’d highly recommend it … but for such a simple system with only two drives and you just want redundancy, ZFS is kind of overkill. The only benefit you might get is the ‘copy on write’ feature, which gives you the ability to mount older snapshots of the drive and potentially recover data that has been deleted or overwritten. (Without unmounting the current version of the partition, you can mount an older version that still has the files that are gone. However, the deleted/overwritten files don’t stay around forever, especially if the drive is nearly full or gets written to often. It’s kind of like a fancy ‘recycle bin’, but it’s smarter about what files to keep shadow copies of – for example, files that existed for longer are more likely to be retained than files that only existed for a brief time.)

    Where ZFS really shines is in more complex setups where you want to take advantage of the performance gains. It can do some pretty cool stuff because unlike most other systems, it’s aware of both the layout of the data on the physical drives and the files and filesystem. In most other systems, those two things are handled by different subsystems that aren’t really aware of one another and can’t optimize things as nicely. For example, in a normal RAID system, the data blocks that are mirrored/striped across multiple drives are always the same size. But ZFS can mirror/stripe data blocks of varying sizes, allowing it to better optimize for a mix of small and large files. You can also do cool stuff like designating particular partitions/drives as file directories or caches to further optimize performance. (Great use for that old fast but small SSD you have lying around.)

    I got into ZFS with very little experience, and it was actually pretty straightforward to set up. If you want to use it just to learn it, I’d recommend that. But for the very simple setup you want, there are probably simpler solutions if you want something that just works out of the box without needing to configure things in the command line.