I don’t usually share what I build. Most of it lives on Codeberg or Github as a glorified off-site backup. 3-2-1 and all that. If I nuke my drive, I can pull it back down. That’s the whole point for me.

A while back I mentioned Pimaps here, a few people asked to see it, so I posted it. Got dunked on for AI slop despite explicitly marking which parts were AI-assisted (documentation and review- flagged with AIP). Similar story with Cliparr. I get it - Lemmy hates AI in any capacity.

What does the community actually expect from devs when sharing a project? I’m not assuming everyone here is a professional dev - though I’d guess the overlap is significant - so I’m wondering where the bar sits.

Polish? Full handwritten codebase? Something else?

How much of the sausage making do you actually want to see?

  • SuspiciousCarrot78@aussie.zoneOPEnglish
    36·
    2 hours ago

    Your recollection is either misremembered or conflated with something else.

    Irrespective, a hunch and a smell aren’t evidence. If you spotted something specific in the codebase, I’m genuinely open to hearing it - “it feels like AI” is doing a lot of j’accuse there.

    As for the spacebar and enter comment - I’m not sure if that’s a formatting critique or something else entirely.

    In any case, none of this is on topic here, with the topic being: what exactly is the expectation? As I said on the Cliparr thread -

    • Don’t disclose - slop
    • Disclose with AIP - not specific enough, still assume slop
    • Disclose more specifically - “slop”

    I’m genuinely trying to get a read of the room. Because when I explicitly described how the sausage was stuffed, I got harassed and called a clanker. I’ve seen that happening on other threads also…to the point at which I question the utility of tagging posts.